TIP: Click on subject to list as thread! ANSI
echo: startrek
to: ALAN PRESLEY
from: CHRIS BRYAN
date: 1997-08-24 01:41:00
subject: Best Trek Series

 > I've been doing a poll on the best trek movie, how
 > about one on the best trek
 > series.  Rate all four series from #1(best) to
 > #4(worst).  Here's my ranking:
 > 1. TOS
 > 2. TNG
 > 3. VOY
 > 4. DSN
 > I will then give four points for a #1 rating, three
 > for a #2, two for a #3,
 > and one for a #4.  Send in the votes!
 > - Pedit Ver 2.5
 > --- ProBoard v2.16 [Reg]
 > (1:370/50)
1) a tie between Star Trek the original series and Star Trek : the Next 
Generation while Gene Roddenberry was alive.
4) a tie between Star Trek : the Next Generation after Gene Roddenberry died, 
Deep Space Nine, and Voyager.
I believe that there has been a lot more potential with the later two series 
that keeps remaining untapped for some strange reason.   They are both very 
good ideas in concept, but no one has been able to tap into whatever it is 
that made the first two series so very good.  It has nothing to do with the 
race or gender of the captains or anything else for that matter.
In some ways, the original series shall always be my favorite of the four, 
because of the warmth generated by the characters and very sincere respect 
they had for each other and the way they would always be more than willing to 
lay down their lives and carriers for each other.  You had this to some 
extent on Next Gen, but it hasn't really been present in DSN or Voyager.  No 
matter whether one likes Shatner's acting or not (I tend to like it myself), 
one can not deny the warmth he put into the character during the 1960's t.v. 
series and the way the character always esteemed his crew.  He was an example 
of a great man - the kind of leader that no one can question why those of his 
crew followed him and continued to stick with him instead of furthering their 
own carriers in a lot of cases.
Also, the main difference between the kind of relationship that Spock and 
McCoy had with each other compared to that of Quark and Odo is like the 
difference between day and night. Anyone with any common sense knows that 
Spock and McCoy never really hated or dispised one another like Odo and Quark 
seem to do, but rather had a very deep, yet unspoken of affection for each 
other.  Spock and McCoy bantering was more akin to that of brothers and 
sibling rivalry than that of enemies.
Though the story line of DSN can get quite interesting at times and the same 
goes for Voyager.
Sincerely,
Chris
--- GEcho 1.00
---------------
> * Origin: Ye Olde Coffee House, Athens, GA, USA
* Origin: The Merry Exchange ... The Voyage into Cyberspace! (1:124/9060)

SOURCE: echomail via exec-pc

Email questions or comments to sysop@ipingthereforeiam.com
All parts of this website painstakingly hand-crafted in the U.S.A.!
IPTIA BBS/MUD/Terminal/Game Server List, © 2025 IPTIA Consulting™.