From: "CE" 

On Mar 25, 7:16 pm, "bramble"  wrote:
> On 25 mar, 19:52, "CE"  wrote:
>
>
>
>
>
> > On Mar 23, 11:48 pm, "ScottyFLL"  wrote:
>
> > > On Mar 23, 10:31 pm, "J Young"
 wrote:
>
> > > We don't all take the word of your bible as truth.  In fact, the
> > > majority of the world's population do not.
>
> > Well, let's look at what the majority of the world's population has to
> > say on the subject of homosexuality. The majority of people in the
> > world are either Christian or Muslim, with an estimated 2.1 billion
> > Christians and 1.79 billion muslims in 2006. These two religious
> > groups consider homosexual acts to be a sin.
>
> > There are also an estimated 376 million buddhists in the world.
> > According to the Dalia Lama, homosexual acts are generally considered
> > to be sexual misconduct, that is to say, homosexuals are considered to
> > be wrong.
>
> > So far, that's 2.1 billion plus 1.79 billion plus 376 million.
>
> > The hindu position is more nuanced. It seems that in hinduism
> > homosexuality is generally recognized but not approved.
>
> > To this could be added the 14 million Jews who have similar beliefs
> > with regards to homosexuality. A quick search on Wikipedia shows:
> > Mythologist and author Devdutt Pattanaik summarised the place of
> > homosexuality in Hindu literature: "though not part of the mainstream,
> > its existence was acknowledged but not approved." In the Manu Smriti,
> > an important Hindu law code probably compiled between 200 BC and 200
> > AD, there are punishments for women who has sex with virgins and men
> > who have sex with priests.
>
> > For the sake of simplicity, let's split the hindu population in half
> > on this issue, although it does seem most disapprove of homosexuality.
> > Tht's another 450 million people. Scientology's founder wrote of
> > curing homosexuals of this orientation, clearly indicating he
> > considered it to be wrong. That's another 500 million people.
>
> > Leaving aside the many other religions in the world, that's already
> > 4.85 billion people who consider homosexuality to be wrong based on
> > the writings in their religious texts.
>
> > So, yes, you're correct. The majority of the world does not consider
> > the Bible itself to be the Truth; there are only 2.1 billion
> > Christians in the world.
>
> > But any overview of the positions held by world religions shows the
> > vast majority of the world's population agrees with the point being
> > made by those Bible passages.
>
> > Homosexual acts are disordered. They are, quite simply, wrong.
>
> I will desagree with you on the figures.  Muslims, Christians and Jews
> are a great population, stop.  Well, you assume they think that,
> because that is written in their holy books, but... this idea is
> forced upon them.  It cannot be considered a real believe of the
> people, but a believe they are subjected to.
> The religious believes are forced over the people.  You only need to
> read a little their holy scriptures to see this is a morality imposed
> over people.
>
> And even if homosexuality is not to be advisable for anyone, it has to
> be tolerated in a secular society.  And what I take out of all this
> arguments is that religious people are a venom for the peace, they are
> hatemongers, and generators of wars and cruelty.  You only need to
> read the Bible or the Koram.
> They are continously justifying all sort of wars and killings of
> people in a genocidal way.
>  These gods, are genocidal gods.  And it is a shame for humanity that
> we are  still praising them.
> Bramble- Hide quoted text -

Wow. That's an amazing rationalization. In fact, it's like a
rationalization sandwich with layer upon layer. I kept looking for the
delicious luncheon meat in the centre. Unfortunately, there was none.

In response to the comment that most people in the world do not believe in
the prohibitions against homosexual acts in the Bible, I agreed - but also
pointed out that there are equivalent teachings in so many religions that
the majority of the world's population does in fact agree with the biblical
teachings against homosexual acts.

To back that up, I used hard data. In showing how the vast majority of the
world believes in these teachings, I did not imply that this large
proportion of the world population justifies these beliefs. I was merely
responding to someone who suggested that a lack of belief in this position
by large numbers of people made it irrelevent.

Nowhere in my post did I advocate the harming or killing of homosexuals and
yet Bramble chose to imply that I did or that religious people hold this
view. This is disinformation. The truth is that the Roman Catholic church
actually encourages people to treat homosexuals with respect, compassion,
and sensitivity and to avoid any sign of unjust discrimination towards
them. Feel free to look it up. It's item 2358 in the Catechism of the
Catholic Church.

As for being forced to believe anything, that's a crock. I'm a Roman
Catholic because I came to believe in that church's teachings. Anyone who
doesn't believe is free to leave the church and anyone who does believe is
free to join. The teachings of the Catholic church as outlined in the
Catechism of the Catholic Church are only descriptive and outline what it
means to be a Catholic in much the same way as Darwin's Origins of the
Species might be said to be descriptive of what it means on a basic level
to be someone who believes in evolution.

Incidentally, Catholics are not fundamentalists. There is no conflict
between Catholic teaching, for example, and evolution.

Someone else tried to muddy the waters in this discussion with the old
argument that there are other prohibitions in Leviticus and, since they no
longer apply, then surely the prohibition against two men having sex must
also not apply. However, that's just wishful thinking from someone trying
to justify the homosexual rights position. In the Bible, there are other
places where some prohibitions are lifted. For example, God later allows
the eating of all foods, which would include shellfish. The prohibition
against homosexual acts is not lifted.

I find the last-ditch attempt to deny the meaning of these passages by
claims of mistranslation to be pretty funny. The organization that has
handed down the Bible throughout the centuries and has had experts working
to understand it and translate it properly is now being accused of
mistranslation by some guy on an internet newsgroup. The fact that the
Jews, Christians and Muslims all agree on the general intent of Scripture
when it comes to homosexual acts doesn't seem to phase this person a bit.
According to this self-professed expert, centuries of scholars from three
religious traditions have all been wrong about their own holy book. That's
an amazing claim. And a pretty funny one.

--- BBBS/LiI v4.01 Flag