TIP: Click on subject to list as thread! ANSI
echo: askacop
to: TOM RIGHTMER
from: RD THOMPSON
date: 1998-01-15 20:16:00
subject: Censorship

Hi Tom, as you were just saying about Censorship....
TR> Let's try a humorous example first and see if it fits your
TR> standard. You receive a brochure labeled, "Cannibal Weekend for two,
TR> make your reservations early and eat the person of your choice."
TR> "Please see the attached photos of people who will be eaten this
TR> weekend and make a carefull selection." I wonder if advertising of
TR> this nature would represent a clear and present immediate danger for
TR> those who are scheduled to be eaten. Some might think this is an
TR> outlandish example, but I bet we could find some perverts who would
TR> pay for this weekend. They might call the spot "Dammer's Getaway."
TR> 
As long as the eaters and eatees were all consenting adults, would you
have a problem with it?  Perhaps the eatees are using this as a form of
suicide and it fits their religion. 
 
TR> Let's take a couple of other examples and see if they work. How
TR> about the open commercial availability of kiddy porn? Could the
TR> demand for such material cause the victimization of children and
TR> represent a clear and present immediate danger? 
I don't consider children (even though they are 24 years old per HCI)
to be consenting adults.  The recruiting, filming and distribution
would all have to be a crime.
TR> How about the open
TR> commercial availability of " snuff films?" Same question.
More difficult.  One would assume that at least one of the
participants was not a consenter.
TR> Using your standard, the information about how to poison a public
TR> or private water supply would obviously represent a clear and
TR> present immediate danger, so this information would be censored and
TR> be illegal. 
No, the placement of it at the local watering hole would be, IMHO.
RD 
sandman@azstarnet.com - A newspaper ISP - Arizona Daily Star
sandman@brassroots.org - A no compromise gun rights organization.
http://www.azstarnet.com/~sandman
___
 X KWQ/2 1.2i X Desk: A very large wastebasket with drawers.
--- Maximus/2 3.01
---------------
* Origin: DPSystem:4285 OS2-WARPED 520-290-8418 USR V.e+ (1:300/105)

SOURCE: echomail via exec-pc

Email questions or comments to sysop@ipingthereforeiam.com
All parts of this website painstakingly hand-crafted in the U.S.A.!
IPTIA BBS/MUD/Terminal/Game Server List, © 2025 IPTIA Consulting™.