From: rfischer{at}sonic.net (Ray Fischer)

stumper   wrote:
>Attila < wrote:
>> On Sun, 25 Mar 2007 20:46:22 -0400, stumper  in
>> alt.abortion with message-id
>>  wrote:
>>
>>> Attila < wrote:
>>>> On Sun, 25 Mar 2007 15:47:45 -0400, stumper
 in
>>>> alt.abortion with message-id
>>>>  wrote:
>>>>
>>>>> Ray Fischer wrote:
>>>>>> stumper   wrote:
>>>>>>> Ray Fischer wrote:
>>>>>>>> stumper   wrote:
>>>>>>>>> Do you exist because you think?
>>>>>>>> I did philosophy 101 in college a couple
of decades ago.  get back to
>>>>>>>> us when you've learned how little you know.
>>>>>>> I read philosophy for seven years.
>>>>>> Ah, so you're a dishonest asshole who uses
philosophy just to
>>>>>> argue, with no regard for the truth whatever.
>>>>>>
>>>>>>> How do you know whether the universe exists or not?
>>>>>> 1st Meditations.
>>>>>>
>>>>> Philosophy is not science.
>>>>> Religion is not science.
>>>>>
>>>>> Science is not good enough for philosophy.
>>>>> Science is not good enough for religion.
>>>> Science is too good for either.
>>>>
>>> That will do as well.
>>>
>>> It seems to be a little silly
>>> just to be against something.
>>>
>>> Can history be scientific?
>>
>> History has nothing to do with science.
>
>What?
>You must be real old.

You must be real stupid.

>Things have changed a lot, I guess.

Or not.

>Some historians are clearly working hard
>to turn history into a social science.

Some wankers are clearly working hard to prolong a pointless discussion.

--
Ray Fischer
rfischer{at}sonic.net

--- BBBS/LiI v4.01 Flag