From: duke 

On Tue, 27 Mar 2007 14:02:01 GMT, Rudy Canoza  wrote:

>> How many amputees prayed to God to get his limb *back*?  I'm assuming you're
>> talking about growing another limb.

>Either way, duck.  No amputee *EVER* got what he
>wanted,

How do **you** know what they wanted after they lost their limb?

>Why is that, duck?  Why does god hate amputees so much
>that he never, ever has answered their prayers?

How do you know what they prayed for?

> but
>sometimes reply "granted" to cancer victims and people
>suffering other illnesses.

That's the key about "removal" - once it's gone, it's gone, be it
cancer or a limb.

>>> Prayer is bullshit, duke.  It has the same effect as
>>> begging a piece of plywood to help you.
>> By your own words above, people are cured thru prayer of cancer, ms, brain
>> injuries, rabies, etc.

>No, duck, they aren't.  They foolishly think they are.

Ohhhhhh, "foolishly".  I see.

>> Can't you make up your mind?
>I did, duck, long ago.  Prayer is bullshit.

Ok, it's your funeral.

>You can't really answer, can you, duck?  Prayer *is*
>bullshit, and you can't answer why god would *never*
>grant relief to amputees.

He does.  He gives them exactly what they need.

duke, American-American
*****
"The Mass is the most perfect form of Prayer." Pope Paul VI
*****

--- BBBS/LiI v4.01 Flag