From: Uncle Vic 

In article ,
 duke  wrote:

> On Tue, 27 Mar 2007 14:02:01 GMT, Rudy Canoza
 wrote:
>
> >> How many amputees prayed to God to get his limb *back*?  I'm assuming
> >> you're
> >> talking about growing another limb.
>
> >Either way, duck.  No amputee *EVER* got what he
> >wanted,
>
> How do **you** know what they wanted after they lost their limb?

How many people would want to lose one?  How many would give anything,
including their sanity, for the chance to restore what they had lost? Would
you agree that perhaps *half* of the world's christian amputees have prayed
for new limbs, in Jesus' name?  Duh.

>
> >Why is that, duck?  Why does god hate amputees so much
> >that he never, ever has answered their prayers?
>
> How do you know what they prayed for?

Answer the question, puke.  Don't you think any amputee has ever prayed to
get whole again?  Why are these prayers *never* answered?

>
> > but
> >sometimes reply "granted" to cancer victims and people
> >suffering other illnesses.
>
> That's the key about "removal" - once it's gone, it's gone,
be it cancer or a
> limb.

What does that mean?  Try to stay on topic, and answer the fucking
question.  The bible says you can pray for anything under Jesus' name and
you will receive it.  You christers have taken that to mean anything within
reason.  Is it unreasonable to pray to god to become whole again, or is it
just unreasonable to pray?

>
> >>> Prayer is bullshit, duke.  It has the same effect as
> >>> begging a piece of plywood to help you.
> >> By your own words above, people are cured thru prayer of
cancer, ms, brain
> >> injuries, rabies, etc.
>
> >No, duck, they aren't.  They foolishly think they are.
>
> Ohhhhhh, "foolishly".  I see.

Your continued refusal to answer the question reveals much here.

>
> >> Can't you make up your mind?
> >I did, duck, long ago.  Prayer is bullshit.
>
> Ok, it's your funeral.

And there you go, you have given up and resorted to christerthreats again.

>
> >You can't really answer, can you, duck?  Prayer *is*
> >bullshit, and you can't answer why god would *never*
> >grant relief to amputees.
>
> He does.  He gives them exactly what they need.

They need new arms and legs.  Name one instance where this has happened, or
admit you are a liar.

--
Uncle Vic  aa Atheist #2011

--- BBBS/LiI v4.01 Flag