Wayne Harris to Anton Shepelev:
> I see your use of commas match my intuition about them,
> but I, so far, have not found an English grammar, or any
> book, that would clearly spell out these rules to me.
I have never consulted grammar books about punctutation, but
I recommend to you the following books from my definitive
list of manuals of English Grammar:
1. The Grammar of English Grammars,
by Goold Brown
2. Manual of English Grammar and Composition,
by John Nesfield
> If I may, let me ask some questions. My intuition says I
> should always isolate a vocative in between commas. ``Hi,
> Anton.'' However, I pretty much never see anyone writing
> that way. Isn't that a grammar rule?
Of course, your intuition is both logical and grammarical.
Nesfield, for example, says under rule 214 (c) for the
placement of the comma:
After the Nominative of an address--
Friends, Romans, countrymen, lend me your ears.
> You wrote ``furthermore, [...]''. That also matches my
> intuition. But I often see people ignoring this comma.
I put that comma because I should pause there were I
speaking.
> Perhaps this is an optional comma. Is it? What is the
> book you go to to cite such rules?
I don't think it optional but Nesfield disagrees:
After an adverbial phrase at the commencement of a
sentence (Here, however, the use of the comma is
optional):
In fact, his poetry is no better than prose.
---
* Origin: nntps://news.fidonet.fi (2:221/6.0)
|