TIP: Click on subject to list as thread! ANSI
echo: 60s_70s_progrock
to: DAVID MARHEINE
from: STUART DUBOIS
date: 1996-09-20 18:21:00
subject: Re: Quiet Sun

D>The notes to _The Greater Antilles Sampler_ say that QS was Phil's
D>pre-Roxy group, and the album (_Mainstream_, I think) is sort of
D>a reunion effort.
Is that the one with the White Noise track?  I have that on tape somewhere, I 
think (a genuine commercial release).
 SD> Phil did a bunch of other stuff outside RM, too.
D>I concur with Kenneth that _801 Live_ is a real good one, 
Some of Eno's stuff grates on me.  "Diamond Head" is brilliant, and the intro 
to "Tomorrow Never Knows" is amazing on headphones.
If he was less restrained,
D>and into leads more than rhythm, Roxy Music would probably be
D>considered more Prog nowadays.  In those pre-punk days, they were
D>certainly exploring more new ground than (fill in the blank).
THey ar4e (cool typing, hmm) often cited as an example of art rock that isn't 
prog rock, if such a separation is really possible (KC gets called art rock 
by mainstream critics, but they're definitely prog).  Kind of like Procol 
Harum, who just did their own thing regardless.
D>even more Not Prog than David Bowie...
I wouldn't have said that, personally, excluding a couple of Bowie albums 
(especially _Space Oddity_), he just doesn't seem prog to me.  I found them 
to be (Clark can fill in the blank here):  Wildly uneven.  Some songs like 
"If There Is Something" are on my "A" list, but much of their work doesn't 
appeal to me.
D>Anyway, Manzanera contributed to some of the better albums by John
D>Cale and Brian Eno, too.  And the Christmas CD Manzanera and Mackay
D>"Presented" on Rykodisc (_The Players Christmas_) is one of the best
D>acoustic instrumental albums in that genre...
He did travel a lot.  That generally speaks well of ability and adaptability 
in a musician.
Stuart
---
 * PW * 
--- WILDMAIL!/WC v4.12 
---------------
* Origin: Tulare Co Office of Educ, Visalia, CA (1:214/33.0)

SOURCE: echomail via exec-pc

Email questions or comments to sysop@ipingthereforeiam.com
All parts of this website painstakingly hand-crafted in the U.S.A.!
IPTIA BBS/MUD/Terminal/Game Server List, © 2025 IPTIA Consulting™.