In a msg to David Bloomberg on , George Jiri Opletal of
3:632/562 writes:
DB> Okay, so here we have a claim from you. Where is this information
DB> from? So far, I see a claim by Klass (backed up by demonstrations
DB> in one of his books or articles) and a claim by George backed up
DB> by...nothing.
DB> So far we have only YOUR word that they are "lies," George.
DB> Meanwhile, most of the rest of the UFOlogical community has long
DB> since properly categorized MJ-12 as a blatant hoax.
DB> That said, if you are serious about discussing this and actually provide
DB> evidence to back your claims, I am quite willing to serve as a
go-between
DB> with you and Phil Klass. It may take some time, but I have sent him
snail
DB> mail before regarding claims made here (the Friedman bet, for example)
and
DB> would be willing to do so again -- as I said, IF you provide some
acking
DB> for your claims.
GJO> I got the above information and the replies to your posts in Skeptics
GJO> from Friedman work.....
Wow. Imagine that. So you are claiming that Klass is all wrong because
Friedman must be right? Please...
GJO> he spent a great deal of time discussing Klass and his claims about the
GJO> documents.
I'm sure he did. He must hate it when his claims get debunked.
GJO> All I can tell is that the documents have not be disproven by Klass.
Because Friedman says so? ROFL!
GJO> Friedman in his majic 12 book addressed all these problems and I used
GJO> them in the post to you.
And you are assuming that he is correct and Klass is wrong. What a great
skeptical attitude to take.
But you didn't respond to my offer about acting as a go-between with Klass.
Why is that? Are you afraid he already knows about Friedman's claims and
could explain them?
--- msgedsq 2.0.5
---------------
* Origin: The Temples of Syrinx! (1:2430/2112)
|