Ol>> If binkd's parameter is intented to have the same
Ol>> meaning as "the default zone" in FTS-5005 than using the same zone
Ol>> number for all "domain" lines is the right configuration (and not a
Ol>> workaround). It is counterintuitive though and the example binkd.cfg
Ol>> files suggests you should use the zone number of the network.
TL> That's how I read the FTSC document myself (taking the wording literally),
but
TL> it is open to interpretation, because there's a little ambiguityin the way
it's
TL> written. A lot of writers make unstated assumptions that, if not
addressed,
TL> can cause confusion. The ambiguity comes from which of two assumptions is
TL> intended:
TL> 1. There is one "default zone", global to your configuration.
TL> 2. There is one default zone per domain.
I don't see the ambiguity. The FTS-5005 is very clear about it:
How should Outbound Areas be named when domains are used?
As always, the outbound area for your primary address (including
domain) is the default outbound.
Separate Outbound Areas are needed for each Zone in each Domain.
These take an identical stem path to the primary outbound, except
that the name of the last sub-directory is changed to the
parameter, plus the zone extension.
For example, if your default outbound is C:\BINK\OUTBOUND
for the outbound holding area (and you are in FidoNet), Amiganet
(zone 39) outbound mail would be held in the C:\BINK\AMIGANET.027
directory instead. Note that outbound areas for domains other than
your primary will ALWAYS have a zone extension, and that zone
extensions are always specified in Hexadecimal, up to .FFF (4095).
TL> BinkD is behaving as though the author has made assumption #2 (but
incorrectly
TL> drops the hex extension on the outbound). The way we've configured BinkD
makes
TL> it follow assumption #1. And from what I can tell, other software seems
to be
TL> fine with that.
There might be some use cases where #2 could be useful. Like having seperat
tosser config for every domain/network (but then I would expect seperate
inbounds too). I'm not sure this was the intention of the binkd developers or
why they decided to do it differently than any other software.
--- GoldED+/LNX 1.1.5-b20180707
* Origin: kakistocracy (2:280/464.47)
|