From: Kelly Pierce
Subject: one woman's war
her fork on her plate, demanding Bonnie serve her some peas. "I couldn't
believe it," she says. "These were adults and they were treating them like
babies, then sending them out in the world. No wonder they can't make it."
Bonnie's college prep classes turned out to be "easy pseudo college
stuff."
She decided to get a suntan instead. No one complained. "I had never even
thought of skipping a class before," she says, but expectations and
standards
were different at WSVH.
Students warned Bonnie that the principal liked to get girls alone in
is
office. "They said he had sex with them," she says now. "I thought it was a
joke or a scare tactic until the house mother and the nurse warned me, too.
It didn't make sense that he would still be there if everybody knew." But
one
day, he cornered her. "He was talking about how pretty I was * * * trying
o
rub himself against me," says Bonnie. "I said, 'If you touch me, I'll have
your job.' He moved away and said he could see me in 10 years, with a baby
in
my arms and two tugging at my skirt, implying that I'd never move up. I
said,
'Well, at least they won't be yours', and I hurried out of there." (Years
later, the principal was charged with sexually assaulting another
17-year-old
student, then acquitted.)
Bonnie told another student about her encounter and the two of them took
cab to a liquor store and bought the biggest bottle of Mogan David wine
hey
could find. That night, on the schoolyard grounds, they drank it all. "I
ad
never had a drink before . . . but I was scared I'd end up being led around
like these people, without a job, without any purpose in life, I had more
doubts about my future than I had ever had," Bonnie says. "I knew then I
would never let anyone know I was blind and have people talk down to me
ike
I was a moron. I'd die first."
The police found the pair drunk and returned them to the school. The
summer
program was drawing to a close, Bonnie recalls, and "they told us to leave
and never come back."
BLIND AMBITION
In the summer of 1972, after her freshman year as a music major at (the
now-defunct) Milton College near Janesville, Bonnie fell in love with a 23-
year-old Milwaukee police aide named Joel Peterson. Bonnie didn't want to
o
back to college, but if she stayed home, her father said, she had to have a
job. She had 24 hours. Bonnie phoned the DVR counselor. He landed her a job
assembling pens at Industries for the Blind. Congress had established
sheltered workshops like this in 1939 as a stepping stone for the disabled.
Because they offer "training," workshops are allowed to pay less than
minimum
wage and they get priority on government contracts. But the truth is, few
f
the blind ever leave sheltered workshops for better jobs. Even today, most
spend their entire working lives at substandard wages.
Industries for the Blind was a union shop so the pay was better than most
workshops and more than minimum wage. Bonnie married Peterson the next
ear.
By 1979, she was determined not to spend the rest of her life "in a job
where
management treated me in the same condescending tone I heard at the school
for the blind." She told her DVR counselor she wanted to go to Alverno
College and major in professional communications. He laughed.
"Then he told Bonnie, 'You're not dealing with your visual impairment,' "
remembers Joel, now a Milwaukee police detective. "And he said Bonnie
hould
go to MATC and learn how to keep house first." That prompted Joel to stand
up, displaying the full girth of his 6-foot-4-inch frame, and he asked, "Do
I
look like a guy who hasn't been fed well?" Bonnie baked homemade bread and
made fresh pasta, trading some of it for rides and bartering the services
f
readers who would record printed matter for her.
The counselor told Peterson the DVR would send her to the University of
Wisconsin-Milwaukee because it had services for disabled students. "I said
was going to Alverno [even] if I had to work or get school loans to pay for
it, and I would major in communication," she says now, "but deep inside, I
wondered whether he was right, that maybe I couldn't do it."
For three years, Peterson boarded a city bus five days a week at 5:30
.m.
to go to her 40-hour-a-week job to earn money for college. At night and on
weekends, she was a full-time student at Alverno. She spent her lunchtimes
at
Industries for the Blind studying on the floor of the women's restroom, her
co-workers' guide dogs helping themselves to the lunch beside her.
On the day her first daughter, Candice, was born, Peterson worked for
eight
and a half hours, took an exam, then went home and wrote a paper. "I made a
deal with the baby that she wouldn't come until I finished," says Bonnie,
who
made it to the hospital just in time for a nurse to deliver the baby.
Bonnie graduated from Alverno in December 1983. By then, she had worked
t
Industries in every position on the pen and pencil line, including quality
control, so when the plant superintendent retired and his job was split
nto
two positions, production manager and sales manager, Peterson applied. "The
president of the company said, 'We'll call you.' "
No one did. Two white non-handicapped males got the jobs. One was the son
of the inspector who approved the workshop's government work. In its
2-year
history, the $18-million-a-year 112-employee Industries for the Blind had
never employed a handicapped individual in any supervisory, managerial or
even clerical position, Peterson discovered. "Maybe I'm not qualified,"
aid
Peterson, "but certainly someone in all those years was qualified to be a
janitor, a secretary or something besides a laborer."
Peterson hired an attorney and filed a complaint with the federal
government, but she was becoming a pariah. Rumors circulated that because
f
what she'd done, blind people would lose their jobs. Peterson re-read the
recommendations her Alverno professors had written, testimonials to her
problem-solving abilities, communication skills and "spirited
determination,"
but she was losing faith.
"I think Bonnie believed that if she filed that suit, they'd wake up and
give her a chance at that job. We all thought she'd be great at it, but
hey
just ignored her," recalls Carol Farina, a supervisor at Industries.
Peterson knew she was in over her head and turned to the two national
organizations that advocate for the blind. An attorney with The American
Council for the Blind phoned, asking for Peterson's attorney's name, and
sent
a letter indicating modest support. The National Federation of the Blind
responded with boxes of documentation involving similar cases and asked
Bonnie to testify before Congress on the lack of upward mobility for the
disabled in the workshops intended to help them.
In January 1985, the U.S. Department of Labor found that Industries for
the
Blind had violated federal affirmative action rules by failing to recruit
and
advance women and blind people. It found no evidence that the firm had
discriminated against Peterson personally.
Within a year, Peterson left Industries. She earned a master's degree in
organizational communication from Marquette University, formed a production
company and created the first cable access television show produced by an
entirely blind crew. But the newest challenge would come from her own
daughter.
THE "BLIND BITCH"
Candice wanted her mother to read Dumbo, but when Bonnie held the book to
her eye, then showed the picture to Candice, the 3-year-old pulled the book
away, saying, "No, Daddy read."
"I still remember what I heard in her words. It was, 'You are stupid. . .
.' It hurt so bad. I didn't care what all those professionals who were
trying
to help me kept telling me," Peterson says. "I knew I had to learn
raille."
It took only two months with the help of the National Federation of the
Blind, which had already taught her to travel with a cane. "It was a
urning
point," she says. "I learned to be proud of being blind once I had
omething
to be proud of." Peterson's confidence was growing, and in 1986, she was
elected president of the Wisconsin NFB. Appointments to the state advisory
Council on Blindness and other boards followed, and Peterson became an
advocate for others.
For six years, a teacher of the visually impaired had worked with a
9-year-
old Burlington girl whose vision was 20/400 and deteriorating, but the girl
was falling further and further behind. Peterson and the child's mother sat
on one side of the table, the special-education experts on the other. When
the woman said she wanted her daughter to learn Braille, the vision teacher
shook her fist in the mother's face. " 'It's almost like you want your
hild
to be blind!' " the mother remembers the teacher saying. " 'Don't you know?
Blindness is like a cancer! It's the worst thing that can happen to you.' "
The teacher's remark took Peterson's breath away. "No. No," she said,
the
worst thing that can happen to a child is for them to be uneducated."
onnie
remembered the incident years later when Sandy Guerra phoned with a similar
case. A Racine School District teacher of the visually impaired had worked
with Guerra's 12-year-old daughter, Melissa McCabe, since she was 3. Yet
he
teacher had never taught the girl Braille.
"She kept trying to make Melissa see. If she stares a long time, five
minutes on a word, Melissa can see almost anything, but for only a few
seconds and it hurts her eyes so bad, she gets terrible migraines," Guerra
says. Melissa was already two and a half years behind her fifth-grade
classmates. The vision teacher had read standardized exams to Melissa,
helping her get the right answers, so her test scores never revealed just
how
far behind she was--until Melissa's regular fifth-grade teacher ended the
charade. "In good conscience, I could not pass Melissa on to sixth grade,"
says the teacher, Rose Mikaelian.
Up until then, no one had ever expected much of Melissa. She was given
half
the class' spelling words, though when Mikaelian recruited a volunteer
tutor,
the girl could do them all. By midd"le school, the tutor was gone and
Melissa
was getting Fs again. Her new vision teacher suggested giving Melissa "10
free bonus points on everything to make her feel better."
At a meeting with school officials, Bonnie urged that the girl be taught
Braille. "You'd have thought the district would have thought of that," says
Mikaelian. "No one challenged Bonnie. She was always in charge." But
Peterson
could not guarantee that Melissa would be taught Braille, and there are
any
others like her.
In 1965, 48 percent of Wisconsin's blind children could read Braille, but
by 1993, the literacy rate had plummeted to 4 percent, less than half the
national average. No wonder, thought Peterson, that the unemployment rate
for
legally blind individuals between the ages of 21 and 64 in Wisconsin was
74.4
percent, the worst of any minority group. And nearly half of those working
were underemployed. "When sighted people can't get around independently,
can't read or have poor social skills, we know that's poor training. When
the
blind can't get around independently, can't read or have poor social
kills,
we think that's the way blind people are," she says.
With the rush to embrace new technology, like giant magnifiers and
machines
that can read a printed page, there was a philosophical shift and many
teachers felt children could manage without Braille, says Marsha Valance,
librarian at the Wisconsin Regional Library for the Blind and Handicapped.
"Unfortunately, that was not always true."
The NFB had looked into the illiteracy of the blind and concluded that
many
teachers didn't know Braille well enough to teach it. So Peterson asked
state
Rep. Fred Riser (D-Madison) to introduce a bill requiring all teachers of
the
visually impaired to pass a test proving they knew Braille. Risser expected
it to be a cakewalk. State Sen. Alberta Darling (R-River Hills), a former
teacher herself, called it "common sense." But the Braille Bill ran into a
blitzkrieg.
The Wisconsin Association for the Education and Rehabilitation of the
Blind
and Visually Handicapped and the larger state teachers' union had myriad
arguments against it: It discriminated against teachers of the visually
impaired because other teachers did not have to prove their competence;
hey
didn't like the Library of Congress' National Braille Literacy Test; kids
don't like learning Braille; and it's difficult to teach.
The unions insisted the state's 825 teachers of the visually impaired had
already learned Braille in college. "Asking teachers of the visually
impaired
to take courses in Braille is like asking teachers of the sighted to take
courses in the alphabet," scoffs Charles Siemers, an MPS teacher of the
visually impaired who fought the bill. He calls Peterson "the blind bitch"
and says she "slandered me and my profession by saying we're poorly
prepared.
Besides," insists Siemers, who is legally blind himself, "if we can get
people to use what vision they have, it's always much, much better."
It might be easier for the teachers, Peterson says, but not for kids who,
being functionally blind, cannot hope to compete with their sighted peers,
even working endless hours and straining what little sight they have.
The Department of Public Instruction, under whose watch blind literacy
sank
so low, hired an outside firm to evaluate the proposed legislation. "The
bureaucrats wanted it their way or no way, and Bonnie Peterson wouldn't
budge," says Andrew Papineau, administrator of DPI's visually impaired
programs. "So I brought in a neutral person."
The "so-called 'independent' consultant had some interesting findings,"
says Sen. Darling. They argued that children are "better off with an aide
and
a computer than to be able to use a $5.50 slate and stylus [the plastic
ruler-sized implement and point that allows the user to punch out a code of
raised dots that can be read using the fingertips]. "If you give people
fish," says Darling, "they have food for a day. If you give them a fishing
rod, they have food for life. That's Braille. But they told me kids
shouldn't
learn Braille because then they'd 'look blind,' " Darling remembers, "and
they said a lot of kids had multiple disabilities so they couldn't learn
Braille." The blind, deaf and mute Helen Keller must have been spinning in
---
---------------
* Origin: NFBnet Internet Email Gateway (1:282/1045)
|