TIP: Click on subject to list as thread! ANSI
echo: educator
to: RON MCDERMOTT
from: MICHAEL MARTINEZ
date: 1996-08-06 18:16:00
subject: Re: IVAN ILLICH 2/2

 -=> Quoting Ron McDermott to Michael Martinez <=-
 MM>End of story.  No loss or harm to society.  If you kill a few other 
 MM>people too, well they had the choice to fly with you.
 RM> Or you landed on them unbidden...
That's life, man.  You're saying the current system has taken the
random element of tragedy out of our lives?  Of course it hasn't!
But it's enslaved everyone more, in attempting to do so.
 RM> Insurance companies were forced to pay out millions in 
 RM> claims, went bust, leaving thousands without insurance.  
In my system, and probably Illich's, there wouldn't be any insurance.
 RM> The uninsured rioted, burning and looting a major city, 
 RM> leading to more deaths, more destruction, more insurance
 RM> claims, more bankruptcies, and further violence... After 12
 RM> months of this, civilization collapsed and the cockroaches
 RM> took over - See how much fun this conjecture stuff can be!
I think you aren' thinking this through well enough.  There's a huge
element of hysteria and exaggeration in your response.
 MM>If you lie to them about your abilities, that's the chance they took.
 RM> They're not allowed to ask; THAT would be discriminatory... 
 
Who says their not allowed to ask or investigate into your background.
If I were going to go on a trip, I would.
 MM>They could have just as easily gone to another pilot
 MM>who they've actually _seen_ flying a plane, or they're neighbors
 MM>told them that he had flown them before and he's reliable.  It's word
 MM>of mouth.
 RM> It's CREDENTIALS... Just a different form....
 
No, it's not just a different form.  THE system of CREDENTIALS is a system
of control and institutionalized values imposed by other people, who 
you dont' even know, on YOU.  It's less free, as you admitted.
 MM>Airline pilots flying drunk.
 RM> Which your hypothetical pilot could do as well...
 
Yes, of course.  But in my system, the public has the freedom to decide
what's good and bad for them.
 MM>What's the difference, except that you don't _know_ he's flying drunk
 MM>because his certification and the power of the airline corporations
 MM>shield him from inquiry.
-mike
--- Blue Wave/DOS v2.30 [NR]
---------------
* Origin: LibertyBBS Austin,Tx[512]462-1776 (1:382/804)

SOURCE: echomail via exec-pc

Email questions or comments to sysop@ipingthereforeiam.com
All parts of this website painstakingly hand-crafted in the U.S.A.!
IPTIA BBS/MUD/Terminal/Game Server List, © 2025 IPTIA Consulting™.