++> From an on going-ish exchange between John Boone,
++> Frank Masingill and David Martorana
++> on "Styles of thought"
Hello John, ..... and many thanks for listening !
DM>> FM>> My aim is only to show how shallow the fixing of labels
DM>> FM>> is in a philosophical debate. Surely we are
DM>> FM>> reaching for something of more intellectual and practical
DM>> Complete systems, however bent in accuracy or value, require that all
DM>> the players be labeled. Such thinking has to round off any "grays" so
DM>> that identifications of the WHOs with, and WHOs against, can be
DM>> painted clear. It is a thinking (often seen on this echo) that
DM>> is absolutely
JB> How can you "lump" -all- "such thinking" into "rounding off" any
JB> grays....?
When "YOU" lump individuals into "TERMS" you essentially lop off
any inconvenient edges "WE" may have. That allows you to define
your prey (us po' foks) to fit conveniently into your contriv-en-ish
logic. That Frank and I won't let you get away with it, seems ever
a mystery to you. My "pointing out your (and some others) "rounding
off" was just a bit of counter contrivancy.
DM>> But do pour out your heart of reasoning as I _MAY_ be wrong
DM>> and John might just be on the verge of admitting that pure logic
DM>> is not the virgin he thinks it is!
JB> I introduced the topic of "Fuzzy Logic", grays, earlier about a
JB> year or perhaps longer ago to indicate pure binary logic leaves
JB> a lot to be desired particularly in our existence, however, even
JB> "Fuzzy Logic", grays, has -some- form or rules to follow. To use
JB> "logic" even "fuzzy logic" without rules or form misses the -need-
JB> for form or structure.
Yes I remember your introducing "fuzzy logic" grays. My general
dispute with you is that you MOST always project North of the
"grays" you claim to know and love .....with more emphasis on
rigidity of form than insight into substance. YES! You know
there are grays but you treat the
"reality-of-truth-to-be-mired-in-grays"
as an orphan to be only occasionally and reluctantly
acknowledged .......Goodness!!!!
GREAT GREAT china LOGIC- yes! yes! chop! chop!
Good and evil be just two _^ ^^ ^_ Take care,
ends of same elephant- /~ee\ /ee\ /ee~\ ... Dave
...with big "GRAY" middle ! // || \\
_||_ _||_ _||_
--- Maximus/2 3.01
---------------
* Origin: America's favorite whine - it's your fault! (1:261/1000)
|