-=> Quoting Evil Doctor to Paul Andinach <=-
PA> A more unusual offshoot of the discussion was a brief diversion,
PA> triggered by Jack Ruttan, into the question of whether the Borg stole
PA> "Resistance is futile!" from their Doctor Who predecessors, the
PA> Cybermen. For the record, the Cybermen never used the phrase. It was,
PA> however, used by a Dalek in the 1964 story "The Dalek Invasion of
PA> Earth".
ED> Who in turn stole it from 40's series and 50's B-movies. They in
ED> turn undoubtedly stole it from the sci-fi short stories from the 20's
ED> and 30's. Who knows who first used those words in those combinations,
ED> and who cares?
Not me. I was just showing off.
ED> Dr. Who and Star Trek readily borrowed and were
ED> inspired from each other. This shows a respect by the producers of
ED> both series for the others work. I have always found distasteful this
ED> tendency by some sci-fi and fantasy fans to grab on to one production
ED> and hate all others.
I try to avoid doing that myself. I have noticed that it happens though,
even at the level of "I love TOS and all the other Star Trek series are
rip-offs by money-hungry studios", which is even more daft.
Paul
... "Bother," said Paul, as he failed to duck yet another Pooh tagline.
--- Blue Wave/Max v2.30 [NR]
---------------
* Origin: The Perth PC Users Group BBS - 08-9497-7772 (3:690/650)
|