> NP>ML> I believe the question of the second amendment being an
> individual
> NP>ML>right has never been to the Supreme Court. The cases that
> have been
> NP>ML>there have all been on narrow technical grounds or perphial
> issues.
> NP>ML>"Miller" for example was quite limited in scope.
>
> NP>I had always thoughtso myself, but apparently not so. The NRA's
> home
> NP>page on the web had some cases.
>
> The USSC has never ruled directly on the 2nd amendment yet... I hear
> it
> may do so soon..
The SC did mention the Second Amendment as one of several examples of
individual rights in U.S. vs. Verdugo-Urquidez, 1990 I think.
Taken from "They Register Cars, Don't They?" by Mark Moritz
Reprinted from the January/February 1991 The Firing Line -
"The Bullet Trap" Arizona State Rifle and Pistol Association
Re: Supreme Court interpretations of the Second Amendment.
The Court most recently mentioned the Second Amendment in dicta in
United States v. Verdugo-Urquidez, 110 S. Ct. 1839 (1990).
Verdugo-Urquidez was a citizen and resident of Mexico, and a drug
dealer. The Mexican police arrested him in Mexico, and brought him to
the U.S., where the U.S. cops arrested him. With the permission of the
Mexican police, the U.S. narcs searched his residence (in Mexico), and
found documentary evidence detailing drug shipments to the U.S.
Verdugo-Urquidez moved for suppression of that evidence as a violation
of the Fourth Amendment prohibition against unreasonable searches and
seizures.
The question for the court: Does the Fourth Amendment apply to
non-resident non-citizens outside the U.S.? The answer: no.
The court's reasoning: The Fourth Amendment protects the right of "the
people" to be secure against unreasonable searches and seizures. Who
are "the people"? According to Chief Justice Rehnquist, the phrase
"the people" was a term of art used by the Framers. Rehnquist wrote:
The Second Amendment protects "the right of the people eAaoce sst.,
Amds .p ); rt. I, s 2, cl. 1 ("The HousnlrYPt) bmeans conclusive, it
suggecdtm rtds oa
ouconsired part of
thato rri n tainm sugge by J. Sultan), then we w te
sooc :mul instructive is the Report of the Subcommitto uS a
The con autrrrrn what is pdedf
Sorry about that, I'll try to bash my software into shape and get you the
rest of the article.
--- FLAME v1.1
---------------
* Origin: The Grotto - Arvada, CO (303) 421-7186 V.32bis (1:104/251)
|