@@> On Apr-27-98 Frank Masingill wrote to David Martorana
@@> on "Self exploring goats"
DM>> Just Reread "Ecclesiastes 12" .....and Yes it IS rich in thought
DM>> provoking "getting-old" symbologies (nice senior citizen poem)! Pretty
DM>> much how I'm starting to feel !!!
DM>> The "Preacher's" beware comment on the still unborn Plato:
DM> "..... My son, beware of anything beyond these. Of making many books
DM> there is no end, and much study is a weariness of the flesh............"
DM> Eccl. 12:11
FM> David, you seem to be assuming that Ecclesiastes was written prior
FM> to the appearance of Plato in the "other" culture. I believe a
FM> considerable scholarship would place that book quite late in the
FM> Hellenistic Age (circa 300-0 (grin) BCE. The notion of authorship
FM> by the historic Solomon isn't, as far as I know, given much credence
FM> except by fundamentalists.
....I think the quoted advice would remain essentially the same
coming from a "fundamentalist" early or a "considerable scholarship"
late!
FM> That verse you quoted could be matched by some of the writings
FM> of our age of Enlightenment and also by the late third millenium
FM> or early second millenium Egyptian writings you would find in
FM> Pritchard's _Ancient Near Eastern Texts_ (_Song of the Harper_,
Was unable to find the "Song of the Harper" in my old copy
FM> e.g). Skepticism, disenchantment, resignation and nihilism are
FM> possibilities in any age where philosophical moorings of a
FM> dominant culture have been lost.
.....Just commenting on the "getting older" text and the preachers
advice not to trust in ungodly (philosophy) books!
_^
_/ @@\_ ... Dave
\\
--- Maximus/2 3.01
---------------
* Origin: America's favorite whine - it's your fault! (1:261/1000)
|