On 05-22-97  19:51, waiting for 22, Henning Schnoor said:
 HS> Replying to Tomasz Nidecki's mail from 16.05.97 about Genesis:
 
 TN> Hah! Luckily I just joined and I'm a great fan of the old Genesis :) I
 TN> remember the first time I've heard "Supper's Ready" it gave me real 
eavy
 TN> shivers :)))
 HS> Finally I found someone who likes this song as much as I do!
 HS> In my opinion this is the best song Genesis (or any other band, by the
 HS> way) has done so far.
 HS> And a question: Do you prefer the version with Peter Gabriel on
 HS> "Foxtrot"   or the Phil version on "Seconds Out"?
 HS> I've always liked Peter better. Unfortunately, I've never heard a live
 HS> "Supper" with Pete on vocals...
Although I'm a Genesis fan I've really never "gotten" "Supper's
Ready."  It's not a bad song or anything, but it just isn't all that
stupendously wonderful.  In fact, the whole _Foxtrot_ album is my
least favorite early Genesis album (not including FGTR, of course).  I
rate the PG albums as follows:
Selling England By The Pound
Nursery Cryme
Trespass
The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway
Foxtrot
From Genesis To Revelation
        Frank
np:  "The Cinema Show / Aisle of Plenty" --Genesis
... No one can hear when you're Screaming in Digital!  
___ Blue Wave/QWK v2.12
--- WtrGate+ v0.93.PRE13.p1 sn 112
---------------