The following is a re-post:
Jean, please don't be offended by this, but I feel you are being
quite naive on the subject of immigration & quotas:
JH> That is just the problem. Each country should not carry its
JH> own quota. There should be an overall quota. Do you honestly
JH> believe that x amount of people will _ever_ immigrate from
JH> Sweden or Norway? Make those set apart places available to
JH> those who desire to come.
[...snip...]
JH> That's what the quota system does. It unfairly tips the scales
JH> toward those who don't desire to come here at all.
[...snip...]
JH> And why do you have a problem with non European immigration?
JH> Could you live with an overall quota or do you favor the
JH> country by country quota? Yeah like the entire nation of
JH> Luxembourg could immigrate in what 2 years?
Jean, you have fallen into a snare here -- your statements imply that
you think ONLY (or MOSTLY) third-world nationals would want to leave
their homelands & immigrate to the USA... Your comments indicate you
cannot fathom Europeans having the same dream of a better life that
would culminate in their leaving their European homes and immigrating
to the USA ... And, to top it off, I would say that attitude is far
more "racist" than what you are accusing the quota system of being.
As for the quota system being racist -- that is hogwash. The quota
is the same across the board, for EVERY nation... as John said:
JS> Limitations are set by Congress and are equally aportioned
JS> between ALL countries with no consideration of race, religion,
JS> etc. So Mexico has the same number of preference category
JS> visas each year as does England.
If the gov't selectively gave tiny numbers to third-world nations
then gave exorbitant figures to a non-third-world nation, then you
could make a case for racism -- BUT by EQUALLY dividing the numbers
between ALL nations, we can assure that every nationality will have
ample opportunities for legal immigration, which is MORE than FAIR!
Does this all make sense? (I hope you're not offended)
[ Shoshona Bieman, Sysop: Shofar BBS @ 714-838-3837 ]
[ Such a *NICE* Messianic Jewish, conservative Gal! ]
[ California "Got Ilk?" Contingent _ Fido @ 1:103/505 ]
--- Aeolus v1.2.1 (#49820837)
---------------
* Origin: Shofar@714-838-3837 Right-Minded in Orange County (1:103/505)
|