TIP: Click on subject to list as thread! ANSI
echo: 60s_70s_progrock
to: STEVEN VAN IMPE
from: GEORGE ERDNER
date: 1997-03-03 00:01:00
subject: New Temporary Moderator

SVI> MD> this echo is in DESPERATE need of HEAVY moderation, or it's just 
oin
SVI> MD> to turn into a 60's/70's classic rock deal.
SVI> I agree. We must preserve this last outpost of civilization. I am 
hinkin
SVI> about making a text file with all sorts of ProgRock bands, hyperlinked 
o
SVI> other. eg. Marillion would be pointing to Pink Floyd, Genesis, ... This 

SVI> make the exploration of ProgRock easier, you start from a band you like 

SVI> names of similar bands, if you like those, you can look up the next
SVI> hyperlink... Unfortunately, I don't know enough about ProgRock yet. So 
t
SVI> have to wait a few decades ;)
If you are going to do that, you should first change the definition of
Prog-Rock the echo is based on away from one that defines MUSIC and
instead one that defines ARTISTS.
SVI> MD> It's already mostly gotten away from us, with all the discussion of
SVI> MD> Black Sabbath, metal bands, The Eagles, Meatloaf for Christ's sake,
SVI> We're still safe, as long as we can keep the B**ch B**s out of here. 
noc
SVI> Wood. (knock knock knock ...)
Again, I have to submit that the Beach Boys songs "Good Vibrations"
and "Heroes and Villians" fit the definition of Prog-Rock, though none
of their other works do. Now, does that fact that only two compositions
out of a band's catalog of hundreds of works fit the definition fo
Prog-Rock mean that those two isolated works must be excluded by the
Prog-Rock police? Does the fact that Genesis has recorded a few songs
that don't fit the Prog-Rock defnition mean that all their works that do
fit should then be excluded?
 * OLX 2.1 TD * Ready, Fire, Aim!
--- RG0511/CDRMAIL 1.06b
---------------
* Origin: LOTL/2 * 412 746 3592 * lotl2.slip.lm.com * USofA (1:129/230)

SOURCE: echomail via exec-pc

Email questions or comments to sysop@ipingthereforeiam.com
All parts of this website painstakingly hand-crafted in the U.S.A.!
IPTIA BBS/MUD/Terminal/Game Server List, © 2025 IPTIA Consulting™.