* Forwarded (from: NETMAIL)
* Originally from carl@commonlink.net
 * Original dated: Thu Oct 23, 18:27
http://www.commonlink.com/~olsen/MEDICAL/IOWA/ames.html
                                  EDITORIAL
                              MEDICAL MARIJUANA
                            LAWS NEED TO BF FIXED
Marijuana as medicine presents a peculiar problem in Iowa. Some say it's
OK.  Some say it's bad.  But this is not a debate between hippies and cops,
parents and kids, good and evil.  It's between state law and federal law.
        The state says medical marijuana is OK.   The feds say medical
marijuana is bad.
        Who's right?  It isn't clear.  But it is clear the conflict is
causing problems.  It is clear the law ought to be fixed.
        Iowa law made medical marijuana legal in 1979, around the time when
the federal government set up a program to provide the drug to qualified
applicants with serious medical disorders.
        Those few who remember Iowa's 1979 statehouse debate say the state
law was passed in response to a perceived easing of marijuana regulations on
the federal level.  Eventually, 35 states passed similar medical marijuana
laws.  Some, like Iowa, went so far as to classify marijuana as a "Schedule
II" drug when used for medical purposes.  (The "Schedule" system is how the
government classifies drugs.  Schedule I drugs have no identifiable medical
purposes, such as cocaine.  Schedule II drugs have some medical purposes,
but access is limited, such as codeine.)
        The Iowa law has been in conflict with federal law, which classifies
medical marijuana as Schedule I, for nearly as long as it's been around.
But that mattered little until a few years ago because the federal research
program provided a legal way for patients, Iowa patients included, to get
access to marijuana.
        That all changed in 1991, when the federal program, coordinated by
the Drug Enforcement Agency, stopped accepting new applications.
        Now, we've got a problem.
        The feds stopped giving out medical marijuana except for a handful
of people still exempt under the old program.  State law still says Iowans
have an access right to medical marijuana, but now there's no legal way for
patients to get it.
        The conflict isn't just a problem on paper.   It really puts Iowa
judges in a bind.
        Consider a Black Hawk County case over the summer.  Allen Helmers
was arrested for violating his probation after he tested positive for
marijuana.  Helmers claimed he needed pot because of a rare medical
condition that left him in chronic pain.  His doctors, right or wrong, said
smoking pot was indeed justified as a last attempt at treatment.  But
Helmers couldn't get a prescription because his doctors faced fines and even
jail time, depending on the amount of pot involved, under federal law.
        District Judge Jon Fister took a common-sense approach in his
ruling.  He said, Look here, folks: marijuana is legal in the Hawkeye State,
but illegal in the United States.  It can't work like that, so we need to
fix the law.  The judge left the record open, and Helmers got to stay out of
jail -- for now.
        Judge Fister was exactly right.  It does no good for a state law to
contradict a federal law.  And that should be fixed.
        One of three things has to happen:
        * Congress has to down-grade marijuana from Schedule I to Schedule
II when it's used for medical purposes.
        * Or the state legislature has to upgrade marijuana to Schedule I in
all circumstances.
        * Or the state Board of Pharmacy Examiners has to create a federally
approved research program that would allow for the legal distribution of
prescribed marijuana.
        It's a tough choice.  Each solution has problems.
        The problem with Congress is that it isn't going to budge.  Some
Democrats would like to loosen marijuana restrictions, but the Republican
leadership isn't about to let pass a measure that looks anything like it's
going soft on drugs.
        The problem with the state legislature bowing to federal law is that
respected groups such as the American Medical Association and the National
Institutes of Health say marijuana may indeed be a valid medicine.  The pot
lobbies claim marijuana relieves nausea, increases the appetite, reduces
pressure in the eyes, tames muscle spasms and helps users cope with mild to
moderate chronic pain.   Even mainstream doctors say pot just may do all
those things, though they would like to see more research.
        The problem with the state Board of Pharmacy Examiners creating a
research program (under the guise of research, even pot can find a legal
home) is that it's incredibly hard to do legally.  In fact, though 24 states
have passed legislation creating state run research programs, including
Iowa, none are currently operating.  Many programs ran out of money; others
had trouble complying with strict federal guidelines and some states
repealed the legislation.
        Medical marijuana critics say there's [a] fourth option, but that's
a matter of debate.  Doctors can prescribe a gel capsule called "marinol,"
which is billed as an acceptable substitute to smoking marijuana.  Marinol
is one of the active ingredients in marijuana.  But each puff of pot
contains more than 400 chemicals, only one of which is marinol.  That means,
not surprisingly, that marinol doesn't work for everybody.  And though
marinol is classified as Schedule II, the Drug Enforcement Agency has placed
special restrictions on its availability.  Consequently, it's very rare for
a doctor to prescribe marinol.
        There simply are no easy answers.
        But because there will certainly be more judges like Judge Fister
who are put in the awkward position of interpreting conflicting laws, both
state and federal lawmakers are duty bound to take up the issue.
        Lawmakers should put aside the politics and the emotions and deal
with the issue.
        They have three choices, all somewhat flawed.   There are arguments
in favor of each, though it's tough to argue against letting Iowans
determine what is legal in Iowa.
        Still, maybe some top federal officials -- who have experience in
this area could forge a compromise.
        Maybe they could say it's OK to use marijuana medicinally.
        If you promise not to inhale.
Ames Daily Tribune
Box 380
Ames, Iowa 50010
515-232-2160 voice
515-232-2364 fax
Tuesday, October 21, 1997
***********************************************************************
*  Carl E. Olsen                *  carl@commonlink.net                *
*  Post Office Box 4091         *  NORML News archived at:            *
*  Des Moines, Iowa 50333       *  http://www.calyx.com/~olsen/       *
*  (515) 262-6957 voice & fax   *  http://www.commonlink.com/~olsen/  *
***********************************************************************
--- 
---------------