TIP: Click on subject to list as thread! ANSI
echo: ipv6
to: Alexey Vissarionov
from: Richard Menedetter
date: 2022-01-18 14:52:00
subject: List of IPv6 nodes

Hi Alexey!

17 Jan 2022 00:38, from Alexey Vissarionov -> Richard Menedetter:

 RM>> With 1 v6 subnet it is easy, you just announce the subnet.
 AV> No: when you need to provide the customer with IPv6, you assign one
 AV> fixed address for a link, and route a /64 subnet through that address.
 AV> Plastic routers (those sold for 20 EUR) deal with this setup just
 AV> fine.

Yeah ... this is what I tried to say.
If you have 1 /64 you deal with it easily also in the dumbest router.
If you have multiple subnets you need a way to configure which subnet is announced where.
This makes it more complicated.

 RM>> If you allow more, you need a way to configure them. (eg. VLANs,
 RM>> different subnet on different LAN port, etc.)
 AV> Or simply route more /64 subnets through that address. Or /56 at once.

This is not really beneficial.
From my point of view it makes only sense if you can split them up into multiple different subnets.
And for 95+% of people it makes no difference, or they do not care.
So ISPs say that this is a business feature, that is only supported by more expensive routers and more expensive ISP services.

 RM>> That is added complexity for a low cost product, where most of
 RM>> your residential customers will have no clue what this is all
 RM>> about. So it makes more sense to offer that on higher tier (and
 RM>> more expensive) services.
 AV> That violates the KISS principle.

Yes, and that is exactly the reason why there is only one /64.
Keep it simple.

CU, Ricsi

... I didn't know international smuggling involved so much lifting.
--- GoldED+/LNX
 
* Origin: You are sick and twisted... I like that in a person! (2:310/31)

SOURCE: echomail via QWK@pharcyde.org

Email questions or comments to sysop@ipingthereforeiam.com
All parts of this website painstakingly hand-crafted in the U.S.A.!
IPTIA BBS/MUD/Terminal/Game Server List, © 2025 IPTIA Consulting™.