-=> Quoting Fred Austin to Paul Andinach <=-
PA> Your argument:
PA> There are billions of stars.
PA> Therefore, there are billions of planets.
PA> The universe is over hundreds of thousands of years old.
PA> Therefore, alien races have been into space for hundreds of
PA> thousands of years.
PA> Therefore, at least one alien race is visiting this planet.
Above: My summary of what was being argued by the person I was
replying to.
Below: My response to that argument.
PA> There's so many holes in that argument that I'm not even going to
PA> try to answer it.
[snip]
PA> Either abduction reports are true, or all abductees are crackpots.
PA> Abductees can not all be crackpots.
PA> Therefore, abduction reports are true.
Above: My summary of what was being argued by the person I was
replying to.
Below: My response to that argument.
PA> My response:
PA> The fault in that argument is that this is not an either/or
PA> situation. Some of the stories could be true, and the rest false. Of
PA> those that are false, some people could be crazy, some could be lying
PA> outright, and some could just have been honestly mistaken.
Just making sure you understood what I was getting at.
Now, you were saying?
Paul
... "I don't eat anything that giggles." - Robert Sheckley
--- Blue Wave/Max v2.30 [NR]
---------------
* Origin: The Perth PC Users Group BBS - 08-9497-7772 (3:690/650)
|