Day Brown wrote in a message to Eddie Sheldrake:
DB> You all might wanna delay huge battery investment... some
DB> techie has made lead plates @2 mils appearantly chemically
DB> doped w/ computer chip technology and with very thing fbgls
DB> separators for incredibly thin layers, and very low plate to
DB> plate resistance. The result is a lead acid battery that
DB> weighs one pound, but will still start a truck engine.
I've got a bunch of experience with regard to batteries, having run a
battery store for about three years. There are always tradeoffs with regard
to anything of this sort, and batteries are no exception! In the case of
the big trucks, you'll most often find three or four "group 31" batteries in
there, which I have *one* of in my pickup. This is a 13" long box (I don't
remember the other dimensions offhand). The ones I sold were available in
two different types. One, that I chose, was rated at 700 CCA (Cold
Cranking Amps) and 180 minutes reserve. The other was rated at 950 CCA and
160 min reserve. The latter had more plates, but thinner ones.
The guy who owned the company told a story one time, about the trucker who
looked at the price of these and didn't care for it too much. So he goes out
and buys four "group 26" (small!) batteries which also happened to be rated
at 675 CCA each, and put them in his rig. Which *did* start, for a while.
At one point there he was, sitting on the side of the road, and these
batteries had been cooked dry.
DB> we can look forward to electric cars that can go several
DB> hundred miles on a charge.
Since the lead is what stores the charge, you can only store so much charge
in a given amount of lead, there's no way to get around that. The more
lead, the more charge you can store. I don't believe that it's possible to
get that much more out of a battery by variations in the manufacturing
process, the big mfr's that are making them now have at least some
competetive pressures to give more if at all possible in their product.
DB> Bolder Technologies [Wheat Ridge CO, (303) 422-8200 fax
DB> 422-8180 PORTABLE DESIGN's jan 97 issue says they've begun
DB> construction on a 120K ft automated manufacturing facilty to
DB> hit full production in 6 months for sub-C cells used in
DB> portable computers.
Sub-C refers only to a size, typically nicads though.
DB> Over the long haul, the design would need far less lead, be
DB> much cheaper to ship and handle, and still be easy to recycle.
I believe that remains to be seen.
DB> Chrysler has powered a dodge with 600 sub-c cells, and no doubt
DB> all the automakers would love to abandon the structure
DB> necessary to hold a 40 lb conventional starting battery.
I could power a Dodge with 600 flashlight batteries! Alkaline types, at
that! Whether it'd be a practical matter to do so and to continue to do so
is another story, though. What structure are they wanting to abandon? The
biggest single problem with this is the fact that you have vehicles out there
that have to be started by a fairly non-trivial electric starting motor,
which can pull up to several hundred amps to do so, especially in low
temperatures when they have to fight the increased viscosity of engine
lubricants.
Yeah, you could build a system that consists of a whole lot of very small
cells, rather than a small number of very large ones. This has the problem
of many more parts, much more in the way of interconnections and power
distribution, and so forth. Yes, it might be possible to overcome some of
this by the sort of technology that's being used to make chips and similar
stuff, though I don't offhand see how. I will remain skeptical about it
until I see something happening, though.
DB> This loss of market share is going to drive down the price of
DB> conventional new lead batteries.
Not necessarily, though competition is always nice. It should be very
interesting to watch some startup company take on outfits like Panasonic
(large in Gels), Exide (around for 100+ years), and others and gain any
significant market share.
---
---------------
* Origin: TANSTAAFL BBS 717-432-0764 (1:270/615)
|