T O K Y O, Sept 29 - Aviation experts discount the theory that
zero visibility in dense smog could have caused the crash of an
Indonesian Garuda airliner, but they have not ruled out another
theory: engine failure caused by smog intake.
The Garuda aircraft, an Airbus A300-B4, crashed into a hillside
plantation 45 km from the west Indonesian city of Medan last Friday,
killing all 234 people aboard.
The flight from Jakarta flew most of its way through a dense
smog that has blanketed much of Indonesia and Malaysia in recent
weeks due to forest and brush fires.
Smog's Role Unclear
Many experts and pilots said it was unlikely that a loss of
visibility could have caused the accident, because pilots are
trained to fly "blind" on instruments and modern airliners are
well-equipped for instrument flying.
But Japanese aviation experts say smog could have affected the
airplane in a different manner.
"It is a well-known fact that jet and turboprop engines can fail
when they fly through volcanic smoke," said Yasutomo Aoki, an avia-
tion commentator and former editor of the magazine Aviation Journal.
"We must study the effect of engines flying through smog,
especially on long flights. We are focusing on the residue of
particles of smog on the engine blades," Aoki told Reuters.
Another expert, former Tokai University aeronautics professor
Haruro Terao, said he, too, could not rule out the effects of smog
on the airplane itself, rather than on the pilot.
"The massive smoke could have affected the atmosphere and it is
not impossible that this had some effect on the airplane," Terao
wrote in the daily Asahi Shimbun.
Aoki said sand-like grains of volcanic debris in the air have
been known to cause engine failure.
The particles block small coolant holes on the surface of
engine blades, which causes overheating. Blades can break off after
heat expansion and these bits can damage the engine's interior.
But one Singapore-based airline pilot with 20 years of exper-
ience, who declined to be identified, said smoke particles from
forest fires are too small to pose any problem to the engines and
wings of modern airplanes.
Volcanic ash is the worst kind and if planes can survive that,
the smoke is no big deal, he said.
Particles Shown to be Dangerous
In 1991, an expert told an international conference on the dan-
gers of flying through volcanic clouds that many planes have risked
disaster by doing so against the expressed advice of airplane
manufacturers.
Captain Ernest Campbell, then the manager of airline support
and flight training at Boeing Co, said his company replaced 10
engines on different planes that flew through ash from the plume
of Mount Pinatubo in the previous year.
"This kind of trouble has also been seen among warplanes during
the 1991 Gulf War (from the sand in the air)," Aoki said.
While the smog that has descended on Indonesia and Malaysia is
different from volcanic smoke, no one has carefully analysed the
minute particles in the fumes and their possible effects on airplane
engines, Aoki said.
"This is the first crash of an airplane that flew for a long
time through this dense fog. We are awaiting word about this possible
factor after investigators study the engine blades and black boxes
from the wreckage," he said.
-----------------------------------------------
Russian air traffic controllers abort strike
MOSCOW - September 29, 1997 06:39 a.m. EDT - Less than an hour
after going on strike Monday, Russian air traffic controllers called
off their strike when state aviation officials promised to pay up to
six months of back wages, trade unionists said.
"The strike has been called off. The head of the Federal Aviation
Service signed an agreement with the head of the union, meeting all
our demands," union official Viktor Budich said.
A copy of the agreement, provided to Reuters, said the aviation
service promised to pay all overdue wages, scrap a plan to cut the
controllers' vacations and index pay to the government-set minimum
wage.
Controllers complained that pay in some regions had not risen in
line with the latest increase in the minimum wage.
The strike involved controllers in 56 cities, including one of
Moscow's four airports, Domodedovo, as well as the capital's air
traffic control centre, Budich said, adding that it froze traffic in
the regions for at least an hour.
Aviation officials played down the impact of the strike, saying
controllers did handle aircraft already in the air. A duty officer
at Domodedovo said that no flights had been delayed, and that the
strike had not actually started before it was called off.
The unions have announced many strikes in the past that never
took place.
Union officials accused the aviation service of hiring non-union
labour and not telling airlines about the planned strike, leaving
some planes in the air as the strike was due to start.
The union said the strike had no political aims.
--- DB 1.39/004487
---------------
* Origin: Volunteer BBS (423) 694-0791 V34+/VFC (1:218/1001.1)
|