NOTE: This Message was originally addressed to Tom Mckeever
from Dempt@eskimo.com and was forwarded to you by Tom Mckeever
--------------------
Date: Thu, 13 Apr 1995 13:15:53 -0800
From: Tom Dempsey
Subject: PPS Pamphlet
To: Multiple recipients of list POLIO
The following is a pamphlet that was developed by the Washington
Easter Seals aimed at medical professionals. You may want to give
this to your doctor.
I have also placed this on the Polio Survivors Page in HTML, Text,
Word for Windows 6.0, and WordPerfect 4.2 formats. Since I use WFW
6.0, I'd appreciate it if someone would tell me how the Wordperfect
file works.
Tom
Tom Dempsey | dempt@eskimo.com
Seattle, Washington USA | http://www.eskimo.com/~dempt/
----
Polio Survivors Page http://www.eskimo.com/~dempt/polio.html
-------------- Enclosure number 1 ----------------
AN APPROACH TO THE PATIENT WITH SUSPECTED
POST POLIO SYNDROME
Originally written by Dr. Warren Anderson and the Medical Advisory Board of
the
Post Polio Program Easter Seal Society of Oregon
MEDICAL ADVISORY BOARD of the POLIO OUTREACH ADVISORY COUNCIL A Working
Advisor
Council to the Easter Seal Society of Washington
Joshua Benditt, MD, Pulmonologist
Evan Cantini, MD, Physiatrist
Dianna Chamblin, MD, Physiatrist
Margarette Forgette, MD, Physiatrist
Bill Kelly, Physical Therapist
Dennis Lang, RN, MPH, Polio Survivor
Lawrence R. Robinson, MD, Physiatrist
Mark Sumi, MD, Neurologist
EASTER SEAL SOCIETY OF WASHINGTON
521 Second Avenue
Seattle, Washington 98119
March 1995
TABLE OF CONTENTS
I. Introduction - 1
A. Definition of Post Polio Syndrome - 1
B. Scope of the Problem - 1
C. Diagnostic Criteria - 1
II. Pathology: Physiologic and Clinical Consequences - 2
A. Extensive Neuronal Involvement in the Average Case - 2
B. Motor Unit Remodeling - 2
C. Decompensation Then Produces Post Polio Syndrome - 2
III. Patient Presentation - 3
A. Prime Symptoms - 3
B. Additional Presenting Symptoms - 3
C. Past History - 4
IV. Evaluation Process - 5
A. Identify Areas of Dysfunction - 5
B. Formalize Treatment Goals - 5
C. Prognosis - 7
V. Resources in Patient Management - 8
A. Neurology Consultation - 8
B. Physiatry (Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation) - 8
C. Physical Therapy - 8
D. Occupational Therapy - 8
E. Speech Pathology - 8
F. Pulmonology - 8
G. Psychology - 8
H. Support Groups - 8
I. Other - 9
VI. Bibliography - 9
AN APPROACH TO THE PATIENT WITH SUSPECTED POST POLIO SYNDROME
Polio survivors are at risk for the occurrence of certain physiologic changes
i
the nervous system which result in a characteristic set of symptoms now
nown
as Post Polio Syndrome. In addition to these unexpected physiological
changes
there are antici
pated complications such as arthritis, scoliosis, and entrapment syndromes
that
frequently accompany paralytic conditions. These anticipated complications
ar
not the problems that distinguish PPS from other diseases of the nervous
system. Post Polio S
yndrome (PPS) is a major chronic illness and one which poses unique problems
to
its survivors and their physicians.
No Diagnostic test exists for PPS, so clinical criteria must be used to
establish the diagnosis. Many Physicians lack training in the diagnosis and
management of a syndrome only recently acknowledged as existing. Patients
are
often uncomfortable with p
hysicians they feel do not understand their problems. They also fear
ncreased
disability, often at the same time they are coping with limitations of
ging.
Patients are often trapped in a "conquer the disease" mentality derived from
the experience of r
ecovering from the acute episode an average of 25 years earlier. This is
incompatible with the lifestyle adjustments necessary for optimal results in
PPS rehabilitation.
I. INTRODUCTION
A. DEFINITION OF POST POLIO SYNDROME
An otherwise unexplained constellation of symptoms which may include
eakness,
fatigue, pain, heat or cold intolerance, and swallowing, breathing, or sleep
disturbance developing in a patient who had paralytic polio. Post Polio
Muscl
Atrophy (PPMA) has
been used as the label for the above symptoms when they include progressive
muscle atrophy.
B. SCOPE OF THE PROBLEM
1987 National Health Interview Survey estimated 1.63 million American polio
survivors (=0.625% of population), 50% with some Post Polio Syndrome
symptoms.
C. DIAGNOSTIC CRITERIA
1. PPS is a diagnosis of exclusion and should be based on a thorough history
and physical exam.
2. Evidence of prior paralytic polio: via EMG, an appropriate history, or
characteristic residual atrophy.
3. Period of apparent stability before any new symptoms. New symptoms may
often be seen after an illness or injury.
4. Exclusion of other conditions (especially motor neuron diseases and
overuse
syndromes).
II. PATHOLOGY: PHYSIOLOGIC AND CLINICAL CONSEQUENCES
A. EXTENSIVE NEURONAL INVOLVEMENT IN THE ACUTE POLIO INFECTION
1. The extent of central nervous system infection by polio virus is not well
appreciated. Infection is far more widespread than anterior horn cells
alone.
Often anterior horn cell infection is largely subclinical due to residual
capacity of uninfected
and surviving neurons. Infection outside the anterior horns is likely to be
largely subclinical also, but may help to explain the disabling symptoms of
fatigue and pain which are subjective and controversial (because the
physiologic basis is uncertain).
2. Ninety-five percent (95%) of motor neurons are infected in an average
acute
infection, with a 50% neuronal fatality rate.
3. There is frequent segmental involvement, accounting for the lack of
symmetr
of weakness.
4. In addition to the anterior horns in the spinal cord, infection involves
intermediolateral horns and dorsal root ganglia.
5. Infection also involves motor cortex, hypothalamus, and globus pallidus,
brainstem nuclei, reticular formation, cerebellar roof nuclei, and vermis.
B. MOTOR UNIT REMODELING IN THE POST RECOVERY PHASE
1. A normal quadriceps has, on average, 200 muscle fibers/anterior horn cell
and a normal anterior horn cell can adopt as many as 1,000 orphaned muscle
fibers.
2. Over 50 % of motor units may be lost without symptoms. (Normal walking
uses
only 15-20% of maximum muscle strength.)
3. Clinical improvement occurs acutely through recovery of mildly affected
neurons, collateral sprouting, and strengthening (hypertrophy) of intact
musculature.
4. Increased demand on surviving motor units results in increased firing
frequency which in turn produces a change in fiber type to predominantly
aerobic "slow twitch" fibers with increased vascularity.
C. DECOMPENSATION THEN PRODUCES POST POLIO SYNDROME
While a single underlying etiology for PPS has not been proven, several
theorie
exist:
1. There is an increased metabolic burden on surviving anterior horn cells
(even in asymptomatic muscles) as they direct more muscle fibers to
ontract,
more often, to achieve the same force of contraction. This leads to
nterior
horn cell fatigue and
can lead to premature metabolic injury, perhaps even cell loss. Fatigued
neurons may be unable to continue to trophically support as many muscle
fibers
The collateral sprouts to some muscle fibers will degenerate. The strength
o
these muscle fibers
will be lost to the motor unit, and a spiral of decline may set in. This
ode
of decompensation augured by fatigue, may be anterior horn cell based. This
appears not to be a static process and there may be dynamic denervation and
reinervation.
2. Another mode of decompensation is muscle fiber based: Rapidly firing
muscl
fibers produce more lactic acid which may not be adequately dissipated.
his
is especially true with any degree of isometric contraction. Muscle fiber
fatigue may, lead to
muscle fiber injury, lost function, and a spiral of decline.
3. Any increase in mechanical load (such as would result from increased
weight
or increased physical activity) or decrease in force generating capacity
(such
as would result from inactivity following illness or injury) may trigger
metabolic failure in m
otor units or in muscle fibers functioning close to their capacity.
4. The resulting relative weakness may lead to joint and muscle misuse and
overuse. This may lead in turn to both arthritis and overuse syndromes.
5. In addition to anterior horn cell and muscle fiber modes of fatigue,
centra
fatigue may also be a factor. Polio virus infection of the motor strip and
the
reticular activating system is well described. A working definition for
central fatigue is:
"Increased mental effort necessary to perform a fixed amount of muscle
contraction". This is very much how Post Polio Syndrome patients describe
their feelings of fatigue, many report hitting a "post polio wall".
III. PATIENT PRESENTATION
A. PRIME SYMPTOMS
A common presentation is a polio survivor who previously had lower extremity
involvement in a well defined polio episode. The patient may have
estricted
ambulation from hiking or jogging, lived a sedentary life, and did not feel
disabled. After a peri
od of relatively stability he or she may begin to notice unusual fatigue and
discomfort and may further restrict activity. Denial of decreased
unctional
capacity may lead to a crisis as the patient can no longer can meet
occupational, social, and famil
y commitments. Persistence and attempts to continue at a previous activity
level may lead to a downward spiral of decreasing functional capacity with
resulting depression and despair. On examination, relative obesity may be
present and weakness is easi
ly demonstrated, often in the "good" leg; limbs considered unaffected are
often
subclinically affected with polio and may present with "new" polio. A
statistical summary of the clinical characteristics of several series of PPS
patients is as follows:
1. Fatigue, Pain, and Weakness are almost always present. Fatigue (89%);
ain
in Muscle or Joint (86%); New weakness (83%) in previously symptomatic (69%)
o
asymptomatic (50%) muscles.
2. New Atrophy (28%); This equates to Post Polio Muscular Atrophy (PPMA).
3. Activities of daily living difficulties (78%) = functional loss. Walking
(64%); Climbing Stairs (61%); Dressing (17%).
B. ADDITIONAL PRESENTING PROBLEMS
1. Pulmonary dysfunction:
Patients with Post Polio Syndrome may suffer from weakness of the breathing
muscles, namely the diaphragm and ribcage. Occasionally, this can be severe
enough to cause symptoms of dyspnea on exertion and even at rest, poor
clearance of respiratory secre
tions increasing the risk of pneumonia, and elevations in the resting
rterial
CO2 level. Measurement of pulmonary function tests in these patients
sually
shows a significant restrictive pattern (small lung volumes) on the basis on
neuromuscular weakne
ss.
If respiratory muscle weakness is severe enough mechanical ventilation may be
required. Small mechanical ventilators have been developed which deliver
breaths through a comfortable plastic nose mask. This is often performed
whil
the patient is asleep
at night and results in improved daytime function.
2. Sleep Disorders:
Patients with Post Polio Syndrome have a high incidence of sleep disturbances
with poor sleep quality and frequent awakenings which may be due to several
factors. However, the most important etiology to rule out is central,
obstructive and mixed sleep a
pneas. Nocturnal hypoxemia and hypercarbia can lead to worsening of daytime
function of the breathing muscles. Nocturnal non invasive ventilation can
e
used in these patients to improve sleep quality and reduce symptoms of
daytime
sleepiness, and perh
aps improve daytime respiratory muscle function.
3. Dysphagia:
Many PPS patients reported some new difficulty with eating or swallowing more
commonly in those with bulbar polio. Video fluoroscopy has been used for
evaluation and has frequently revealed pharyngeal constrictor weakness.
Laryngeal penetration and loss
of the cough reflex may occur without symptoms, suggesting an underestimation
o
the presence and severity of dysphagia in this population. Many patients
have
already employed compensation such as altering diet, cutting solids into
small
pieces, chewing
it thoroughly, taking small sips of liquids, eating slowly, and using
postural
maneuvers. Most patients with dysphagia had also experienced some
progressive
speech difficulty such as increased hoarseness, weakness, or slurring.
4. Cold intolerance (29%):
Limbs may be cold and cold exposure produces weakness. This is thought to be
due to intermediolateral column involvement resulting is vasoparesis, venous
pooling, and excessive heat loss.
5. Degenerative arthritis:
A joint that is biomechanically disadvantaged may develop degenerative
arthritis.
6. Social and psychological problems:
Long term disability and denial may result in social and psychological
problems
C. PAST HISTORY
1. Average age of polio onset is 7 years. Median time to maximum recovery
is
years. Median period of stable neurologic and functional status is 25
ears.
Median post polio symptom duration before patient presents for evaluation is
5
years.
2. Variables associated with shorter interval to PPS: greater severity and
greater age.
3. Initial symptoms are most frequent in the lower limb most affected in the
acute illness. (Upper extremity weakness is easier to compensate for without
overuse resulting.)
4. The onset is usually insidious but is frequently precipitated by injury,
illness, bed rest, or weight gain.
IV. EVALUATION PROCESS
A. IDENTIFY AREAS OF DYSFUNCTION
1. The history is especially useful in identifying fatigue, dysphagia, sleep
disorders, and alteration in activities of daily living.
2. The Neurologic exam will identify atrophy or weakness and verify that
reflexes are not increased. Pay special attention to the "good" limb as
significant weakness may be present of which the patient has never been
aware.
With leg muscles, functiona
l tests must be used because manual testing may not detect quadriceps
eakened
to 30% of normal even though this is sufficient strength for routine daily
activities. Seek a mechanical advantage in manual muscle testing: Test the
triceps or quadriceps w
ith the elbow or knee flexed more than 90 degrees. Test the psoas in the
supin
position.
3. The general physical exam and biomechanical exam note obesity, joint
deformity, overuse syndromes, and scoliosis.
4. Electromyography may be requested when needed to document previous
anterior
horn cell disease (especially when the previous history of polio is in
doubt).
EMG can also be used to rule out other neuromuscular pathologies or to
identif
subclinically
involved muscles.
5. CK elevation may be seen in patients but may not correlate with
progressive
weakness.
B. FORMALIZE TREATMENT GOALS
After the diagnosis of PPS is established, a patient conference is a
convenient
way to formalize treatment goals and begin patient education. These areas
should be addressed:
1. Lifestyle Modifications:
This item is the "sine qua non" of all attempts at successful management of
PPS
At the time of formal diagnosis, patients are often desperate, yet imbued
wit
a belief in their own ability to overcome their disability through the "no
pain, no gain" app
roach. This approach may have served them very well after their acute attack
o
polio many years ago but is now actually self destructive. Persistence in
thi
approach of "overcoming" illness has led to a spiral of deteriorating
function
and frequently
a p
--- WILDMAIL!/WC v4.11
1:374/22.0)
---------------
* Origin: SPACECON Med/Disab. BBS - Home of ye POST_POLIO ECHO.
|