DIA SPRIGGS was thinking about Re: ADD and ADHD and keyed into
cyberspace:
DS>Also pycnogenol has proven extemely effective in treating this; some
DS>Calif. drs. have taken children off ritalin totally with the use of
DS>it.
I posted on this message yesterday. Last evening I found something that
I wrote about Pycnogenol over a year ago:
As many know, I use a fiberoptic link and have been home sick with
pneumonia for three weeks. Thus, I have a lot of time on my hands. Also,
many of you know that I adamantly believe that Anti-oxidants, have no
demonstrated use in the treatment of ADHD. Well, I decided I should
really do a search and learn more about it. Some accuse me of being
"narrow minded". I tried to approach this with an open mind.
So I surfed and searched. I found that Pycnogenol's "guru" is a fellow
by the name of Richard Passwater, Ph. D. I used his name and found
NOTHING on MEDLINE. However, using ALTAVISTA I got back over a hundred
hits. Some were duplicates. I also searched on Pycnogenol and found
several hundred references. I limited it to Pycnogenol and ADHD. Still a
few hundred. Since I had the time, and nearly instant netpage turning at
500,000 baud, I read them all. Every single one. 473K worth of
documents. Very enlightening.
Pycnogenol seems like a pretty good product for about sixty things or
so, according to Dr. Passwater. he seems to be a pretty straight guy who
honestly believes in this. For those problems, I'll try it. And let you
know. I am still a bit skeptical about supplements as there are even
more studies saying that anti-oxidant supplements do little. Some of his
articles were clearly written for sales. But, as I said, I'll try it.
However, what I found MOST CURIOUS, was that Dr. Passwater does not
claim anywhere that it is useful in the treatment of ADHD. In fact, he
specifically seems to omit any direct reference to treatment of
conditions such as mental or emotional disorders. He has posted as
recently as February 26, 1996.
However, the MLM salesmen all claim that it will help. They all do. They
do not say Dr. Passwater claims that it is a valid treatment for ADHD.
They are too clever for that. They try to leave the impression that he
agrees.
Personally, I do not think so.
The MLM salescreeps usually use several scare tactics to "convince"
people that Ritalin (never methylphenidate, Cylert, DAS, Adderal, etc.,
always the eeeeevil Ritalin) is a bad thing. They use "testimonials".
One of the most commonly used ones is the yarn about the parent who had
their child taking Ritalin for five (or four or six, it is YOUR choice)
years and watched their child wither away or grow two heads. (What sort
of parent would just watch for five years?)
That is the "horrible side effects" lie. While MPH does have several
side effects listed, they are not common, often mild and disappear in a
week or two.
One of the other ones that I particularly like is the growth stunting
yarn. It usual goes like this, my eight year old is small for his age.
Both my husband and I (it is rarely the husband doing the testimonial)
are tall, and our kid is shorter. He seems so small.
[So did mine, until puberty, and now we see eye to eye.]
-----------------------------------------------------------
Now, we do see many people drop into alt.support.attn-deficit who have
tried Pycnogenol. Their testimonials are very instructive. They fall
into two categories:
1. I used Pycnogenol for my child and saw absolutely no
response.
2. I know of this kid who was on Ritalin and his mother put him
on Pycnogenol and he is now Ritalin free. He had to be weaned off
Ritalin, first.
1. is personal experience.
2. is baloney. Therapeutic doses of MPH are not addictive. It is not
personal knowledge.
Watch out for the term "great results". It usually means that someone
has made a lot of money, or wants a lot of your money.
BTW, I used Pycnogenol for my leg circulation. Years ago, during a
winter I spent in extreme northern Pakistan, I picked up a touch of
frostbite. My circulation in my legs is not so good. Pycnogenol is
supposed to help. I neither received subjective or objective benefit
from it.
It is only an anti-oxidant. So is Vitamin C. Same chemical action.
The Few. The Proud. The Chosen.
markprobe@aol.com
---
* CMPQwk #1.4 * UNREGISTERED EVALUATION COPY
---------------
* Origin: PC BBS : Massapequa, NY : (516)795-5874 (1:2619/110)
|