TS> In other words, some oversimplified sales
TS> literature to comfort people trying
TS> to have incompetent volunteers pretend to
TS> be able to handle things they should
DS> Well I'm a volunteer and I don't have a degree in sound, but I have
DS> been around sound systems as a musician for 25 years, and audio has
Still, I'd guess you know the type of church volunteer I meant.
TS> note that they likely suggest tests with
TS> speakers disconnected to avoid being
TS> blamed for destroying garbage better
TS> taken direct to the dumpster as found in
DS> Fortunately in this case the church actually has some nice equipment,
DS> such as EV, Crown, QSC, Rane, but there are no names visable on the
It happens, though it's amazing how low priority good speech intelligibility
is to many churches, as well as how poorly installed some systems with decent
equipment may be.
DS> hung from the ceiling and are spread out in a semi-circle to cover the
DS> room, with 2 bass bins and 4 mid/high cabinets. The mid/high cabinets
DS> have a nice sound, but I don't like the bass sound, as it is very
DS> subdued and indistinct - maybe that is what churches like?
Hardly. Some cathedrals are designed for long reverberation times with
unreinforced choirs and organs. They're usually a pain for sermons, and lend
themselves to distributed speaker systems. Intelligibility from
reinforcement audience members don't fully distinguish from direct sound is
the goal.
TS> Dare I mention architectural acoustics,
TS> and differences between music fidelity
TS> and speech intelligibility?
DS> That is the real problem, and you can read about it a bit more in a
DS> previous message.
Simply deadening things as your other post suggests can be a poor solution,
depending on other factors. Controlling live and dead surfaces is complex
enough it's not a good do it yourself job, though substantial consulting and
treatment addressing those issues can get expensive fast if qualified
engineering services are used. That leaves considering work arounds, as
suggested in my previous message. The sharper band amp is a poor solution.
Terry
--- Maximus 2.01wb
---------------
* Origin: Do it near resonance! (203)732-0575 (1:141/1275)
|