The message from Scott Rhodes rises higher:
CR> First off, I think the opening is a nod to Zeppelin's "Stairway..."
SR> No, not really. Both are just trying to capture a fairly mediaeval
SR> sound, and both do...well, okay at it.
Medieval? Well, we'll disagree again.
CR> The overall form of the song is a nod to "Supper's Ready" and side 2
CR> of _Abbey Road_ (in a way).
SR> Again, I disagree. There's no equivalent of "Willow Farm", for
SR> example, nor of "How Dare I Be So Beautiful?" or "As Sure As Eggs Is
SR> Eggs". About the only similarity is the closing section, which isn't
SR> even the equivalent of the closing section of SR.
"Supper's Ready" has separate themes; "Grendel" has separate themes.
That's what I meant. You can't disagree with that similarity.
CR> There's Fish's voice which sounds like
CR> Gabriel in Genesis in 1971 to 1972.
SR> No more so here than anywhere else, though.
I think Fish's voice changed over the years to be more unique.
CR> Then there's Rothery's guitar
CR> which, to me, has a thinner Hackett sound. It gets *very* Hackett
CR> like from 7:00 through 9:00 minutes into it.
SR> This I can see.
No way -- you agree?! :-)
NP: "Hole in the Wall" -- Bela Fleck and the Flecktones
--------------------------------------------------------------
- Clark Ray -
- email: clarkray@psnw.com -
--------------------------------------------------------------
... it's one-o'clock and time for lunch, hum de dum de dum...
___ Blue Wave/QWK v2.12
--- WILDMAIL!/WC v4.12
---------------
* Origin: Tulare Co Office of Educ, Visalia, CA (1:214/33.0)
|