TIP: Click on subject to list as thread! ANSI
echo: mens_issues
to: All
from: Dg411{at}freenet.Carleton.Ca
date: 2005-03-07 12:06:00
subject: Re: Looking for `reasoned discourse`

"JWB" (jwb3333__takeoutallthis__{at}excite.com) writes:
> "John Royer"  wrote in message
> news:OAZWd.6684$fW4.221510{at}news20.bellglobal.com...
>> Doug, I've posted this twice. Nobody seems to want to discuss this:

Well, in my case, because I agreed with it. :-)

>> Ever heard of the Low Ball Technique, or the Foot in the Door technique?
>>
>> One could argue that the satements by the radical feminists are just that,
>> radical statements. That they really have no value to a civilized society.
>
> This I agree with. I don't listen to radical anything, male or female.

But, legislators do. Catherine MacKinnon wrote some legislation in
both Canada and the US, and shes a close writer mate with man hater
Andrea ( " All hetero sex is rape " ) Dworkin.

>> Hitler did much the same to the German population in getting them to
>> accept
>> what was done to the Jewish people. Make outrageous statements, then make
>> a statement not quite so outrageous maybe something like"Boy's are too
>> aggressive in school". Something that many can buy into. That's how it
>> starts.
>
> Let's not compare feminism to the Nazi's ok?

Why not ? Both apply the repeated practice of The Big Lie.

>> Look at our culture today" boys bad, girls good, fathers bad, mothers
>> good,
>> the court system, women routinely recieving lesser sentences for the same
>> crimes, or even heinous crimes being excused with " It's her husbands
>> fault"
>> as was the Andrea Yates case. Men routinely hit by women in the media, we
>> consider it funny.
>>
>> And YOU ACCEPT IT!
>
> Ok, here's where your argument falls apart (actually, it isn't an argument
> at all).

No proof offered ? Claim fails.

> You say things like "look at today's culture"... well, I do look at
> today's culture, and I do not see what you are describing. I do not see
> "boys bad, girls good" etc etc.

Operative words: " I do not see. "

Read " Spreading Misandry; The Teaching Of Contempt For Men In Popular
Culture ", Paul Nathanson & Katherine Young, 2001, McGill/Queens Univ
Press. It details the mass misandry that is accepted in society today.

Heres an example, one that I replied to a Florida paper about. They
did a glowing puff piece about a company that, among their products,
sells t-shirts with slogans on them. Among those shirts were ones
with " Boys are smelly, throw rocks at them. ". These shirts were
available in major stores, over 9,000 in the US, and radio host
Glenn Sacks ran a campaign to get them out.

Now, imagine the hoohaw, if a firm had in even one store, shirts
that said " *girls* are smelly, throw rocks at them. ". Exactly.

And, this is not an exception, I can find more examples every day, even
without the Web.

> In short, it doesn't exist except in your own mind.

Wrong. Ibid.

> You are taking your overall opinion and applying it to the whole culture.

Wrong. Ibid. *You* are doing this, not he.

> You may as well be Bill and say 'things today are terrible' with no real
> proof -  NOTHING except your own personal gut feeling. And no, posting
> feminist articles is meaningless -

.... Because you won't accept proof that your man hating ideology is
exactly that. Uh huh. Got it.

>> But you know what? It's not us that have to be worried. It's our sons and
>> grandsons. What kind of world will they inherit? More importantly, will
>> they be allowed to breed?
>>
>> Hence the term FEMINAZI
>>
>> The term is apt.
>
> You learned the term from Rush Limbaugh. Congrats, you've proven
> yourself a sheep.

Ad hominum. Fifty yard penalty.

>> As far as reasoned arguments I offer this as to why I'm no longer
>> interested in discourse
>
> You offer nothing except your own gut feelings on society.

Lie. I offered multiple quotes from still prominent and acclaimed
Feminists, as to their real views.

>>> You have an odd notion of proof.
>>>
>>> All it seems to require is a peripherally related out-of-context quote
>>> from a few individuals and then you assert some sort of
"proof."
>>>
>>> Or were you trying to prove your lack of interest in reasoned discourse?

Yep. JWB is using old Big Lie methods to deny the misnadry on her nose.
No news there.

>> Could anyone within the German population have taken the statements made
>> by Hitlers progaganda machine and stood up?
>
> enough... invoking Godwin

Enough. Invoking Dworkin.

Andre

--
" I'm a man... But, I can change... If I have to... I guess. "
                                    The Man Prayer, Red Green.


--- UseNet To RIME Gateway {at} 3/7/05 12:05:09 PM ---
* Origin: MoonDog BBS, Brooklyn,NY, 718 692-2498, 1:278/230 (1:278/230)
SEEN-BY: 633/267 270 5030/786
@PATH: 278/230 10/345 106/1 2000 633/267

SOURCE: echomail via fidonet.ozzmosis.com

Email questions or comments to sysop@ipingthereforeiam.com
All parts of this website painstakingly hand-crafted in the U.S.A.!
IPTIA BBS/MUD/Terminal/Game Server List, © 2025 IPTIA Consulting™.